Baking is an enjoyable hobby. It helps you to pass your leisure time as well as makes you eat healthier homemade dishes. However, if you want to enjoy baking to its fullest, you must have the correct understanding of baking tools. If you ever tried to make loaves at home, you probably are familiar with the Pullman loaf pan. It is popularly referred to as the sandwich bread pan too. It is an excellent baking tool that you can include in your baking arsenal.However, the issue is, there are many Pullman loaf pans available out there. So, how to distinguish the best Pullman loaf pan among so many options you may wonder! Don’t worry, we got your back very solidly. In today's segment, we will be looking at some of the sought-after Pullman loaves pans that you can try. We will be presenting you ten of the better loaf pans that you can consider buying along with a buying guide. So, let’s start!
List of The 10 Best Pullman Loaf Pans
1. USA Pan Bakeware Pullman Loaf Pan
Topping our list is a pan coming from a renowned brand in the baking industry. Yes, we are talking about the USA Pan. Their Bakeware Pullman Loaf Pan would be our go-to recommendation if you wish to buy a Pullman loaf pan.
It is a very high-quality alloy steel pan that can provide you with a long service without any major headache. It is a rectangular loaf pan with a dimension of 13 x 4 x 4 inches.
Commercial Grade Loaf Pan
Constructed from heavy-duty aluminized steel, this is a beautiful pan. It includes the lightweight nature of aluminum along with the strength of stainless steel. So, durability is not a major concern with this pan.
The fluted wavy arrangement of the pan gives it a unique appearance. This pattern ensures that the heat is spread evenly whilst baking your bread. This arrangement also aids airflow, making the bread to be baked nicely.
Nonstick Americoat Coating
This pan features a USA Pan patented silicone-based nonstick coating named ‘Americoat’. Despite being a silicone coating, it doesn’t induce any harm as it is free from PTFE, PFOA, and BPA particles.
A nonstick coating helps a lot during baking. It ensures that the baking ingredients don’t get stuck to the pan which can mess up your food and result in a bad baking experience for you. So, it is very useful.
This Pullman loaf pan bakes delicious bread that is soft inside; however, crispy on the outside. Its lid cover is a bonus that seasoned bakers who are willing to explore will appreciate a lot.
The pan's cover doubles as a bread-holding container. The lid slips on top of it, transforming the anticipated spherical into a fully horizontal one. This helps it to bake perfect loaves and elevate your baking experience.
2. CHEFMADE Mini Pullman Loaf Pan with Lid (Square)
The next Pullman loaf pan comes from a yet popular baking cookware brand named ‘Chefmade’. Their square Mini Pullman Loaf Pan is the best square loaf pan available in the current market. It sells like hotcakes!
Here you will witness a change in build material. Ditching alloy steel, Chefmade chose carbon steel as their material of choice for it. This mini pan is champagne gold in color and has a dimension of 4.5 x 4.5 x 4.2 inches.
Superior Build Quality
With a thickness of 0.5 millimeters, this pan features commercial-grade carbon steel with thick borders. The reinforced borders let it retain its usual shape even after repeated use. It also prevents the pan from warping.
Similar to the previous pan, this pan also comes with a nonstick coating. Well, such coatings are quite common in the bakeware industry. However, unless coming from a reputed brand, you can’t judge if they are sustainable or not.
Safe and Easy
The silicone coating it features is food-grade. Moreover, it doesn't release Teflon or any harmful substance at high temperatures. The pan is PTFE and PFOA-free. So, you can bake without a headache!
This loaf pan can achieve excellent non-stick capabilities with less natural cooking oil. Less cooking oil means less baking time and low energy consumption. Furthermore, it is easier to release as well as to clean.
Chefmade places high importance on client happiness and tolerates no quality issues. You can notify them if you are dissatisfied with the pan's construction or functioning. They will work with you to find a solution to your problem.
They can either reimburse you or give you a free replacement, depending on your preference. When viewed through the eyes of an average consumer, such after-sales support is much appreciated.
3. CHEFMADE Pullman Loaf Pan with Lid (Rectangular)
Coming on number three is again Chefmade. This one is a rectangular Pullman Loaf Pan with Lid. It has an extended room for you to bake a larger quantity of bread at once. This is our second choice rectangular loaf pan on this list.
Chefmade went with carbon steel on this one as well. Carbon steel is a very tough material that can serve you for a long time. This load pan has a dimension of 8.4 x 4.8 x 4.5 inches and comes in three different colors.
One Pan - Two Uses
This Chefmade Pullman loaf pan with cover can be used to create square bread as well as bread toast. You may utilize the cover or not, depending on your preferences, thanks to its creative intimate design.
The included lid can multiple as a bread holder too. The pan is coated with a nonstick coating as well. Despite its silicone use, it is food-grade, PTFE, and PFOA-free. So, it doesn’t release any harmful particles while baking.
This loaf pan features three holes on the base that serves as an air passthrough. The bottom vent model allows the bread to be cooked more evenly and absorb a greater flavor. This enriches the taste of the bread.
However, when you are baking with batter, a piece of paper must be placed on the base to avoid spilling. The pan also features a wave pattern that lets the heat spread out on the surface evenly. This is very important in baking.
This high-quality bread loaf pan with a cover will last for years. If for any reason, you no longer believe that this pan is the correct decision for you, Chefmade will purchase it back from you at any time, risk-free.
This is an interesting opportunity. Chefmade always innovates in terms of after-sales and they have done it here again. So, it is like a zero-risk investment for you and we highly recommend it.
4. Monfish Pullman Loaf Pan with Cover
In terms of looks and functionality, the next product of this list claims straight As. With an elegant design and all the right functionality, the Monfish Pullman Loaf Pan with Cover has won our recommendation for a good loaf pan.
Gold in color, this Pullman loaf pan is made of solid aluminum. Thus, it is very sturdy and lightweight. It comes with a lid which is a must for Pullman pans. It is rectangular and features a dimension of 8.5 x 4.75 x 4.38 inches.
Spread The Heat!
Having wavy patterns running through its entire body, this aluminum-made Pullman loaf pan has excellent heat conduction. The special pattern allows the pan to spread the microwave heat evenly across the surface and bake properly.
There are also three holes at the bottom of this Pullman pan that aid gentle airflow while baking. Overall, the construction and heat dissipation methods of this loaf pan are splendid and we like it.
The thick aluminum alloy allows this pan to resist warping and show rigidity. There is reinforced aluminum in the borders that keep the pan solid. Even after using it for a long time, it continues to feel sturdy in hand.
Weighing at 1 pound, it is very lightweight. However, it got all the necessary features going for it. For instance, nonstick coating, BPA-free, non-Teflon, PTFE, and PFOA-free certification, and so on.
Easy to Clean
The Monfish Pullman Loaf Pan is very easy to clean. You can just rinse it with lukewarm water and maybe a bit of liquid soap. However, don’t use any harsh chemicals on it as that may remove its nonstick coating.
Speaking of removing the nonstick coating, don’t try to wash in the dishwasher. There’s no mention of it being a dishwasher-safe product. So, wash it by hand, don’t put it in the dishwasher; not even in the first rack.
5. Focus Foodservice Pullman Bread Pan
Next on our list is a Pullman Loaf Pan that is very famous in the commercial scenario. It is the Focus Foodservice 16 by 4-Inch Single Pullman 2-Pound Bread Pan. It is a heavy-duty aluminized steel bakeware.
If you have a large family or want a large-size Pullman Loaf Pan, this might be an ideal choice for you. As made per commercial demand, this product should be one of the most sturdy pans features on this list.
This Pullman loaf bakeware is made of heavy-duty aluminized steel, a three-ply material that combines durability, stiffness, and excellent heat transmission. The rigidness of this pan is unparalleled to any other.
The carbon steel in this loaf pan is sandwiched between two layers of strong corrosion-resistant aluminum (3003) alloy. It has an unrivaled level of durability because of its folded construction and reinforced cable support.
Solid Heat Transmission
It has a flat surface yet it is very good at transmitting heat, thanks to its silicone glaze aluminum steel. The thick 0.6 mm body conducts heat pretty well and distributes it evenly on the base of the pan.
The even heat transmission and the large storage container allow this Pullman loaf pan to take care of 2 lbs of dough at once and turn it into bread. It provides an easy release for baked foods, making it a good choice.
Before using this pan, you need to season it properly. There is no mention of nonstick technology anywhere in the product. So, we assume it doesn’t feature that technology, thus needs to be seasoned before use.
However, you can wipe it clean afterward. It can be cleaned with cold water and mild soap as well. You must dry it immediately after washing as not drying exposes it to oxidation and it may start to rust.
6. Twscvc Pullman Loaf Pan with Lid
A product of China, this product is a good value for the price. It is from a brand named ‘Twscvc’. Made from high carbon steel, this Pullman loaf pan comes with a lid and a 6-months warranty.
This nonstick loaf pan weighs around 1 pound and features a dimension of 7.6 x 4 x 4.5 inches. It comes in only one color, gold. However, the gold color on this pan is very muted and almost unrecognizable.
Make Bread and Toast
As this Pullman loaf pan comes with a lid, it can be used to make both loaf bread as well as bread toast. The lid offers some degree of versatility to this loaf pan, that the pans without any lid fail to provide.
The coating on this pan is pretty strong. So even after repeated use, no complaints from customers could be found about coating peel. It makes an outstanding loaf of sourdough sandwich bread.
Not many baking pans claim to be dishwasher-safe. It is usually recommended to wash the loaf pan by hand. However, Twscvc claims their pan to be dishwasher-safe which is very interesting.
If you wash this pan on your dishwasher, ensure that you put it in the top rack. There’s still some room to doubt if it can withstand the dishwasher regularly. We recommend you wash it by hand if you want to use it for long.
Twscvc will offer a complete refund or send you a replacement if you have a problem with your order within six months. This deserves a welcome gesture. Companies providing after-sales on pans is a great addition.
7. TA BEST UgyDuky Bakeware Pullman Loaf Pan
Crafted from tin and aluminum, the TA BEST UgyDuky Bakeware Aluminized Steel Pullman Loaf Pan with Cover is a good baking pan for a reasonable price. It is a product of China.
The pan is 13 x 4 x 4 inches in dimension. You can easily make a 1.5 lbs loaf of sandwich bread in this Pullman pan. It weighs around 1.65 pounds.
The pan is made of tin and aluminum. While this pan doesn’t feature the highest tier of materials or technology, it gets the job quite well. It is solid in baking and feels sturdy in hand.
The borders of the pan are reinforced with aluminum wires. So, the chances of it getting wrapped are relatively slim. It has very good heat conduction. It has five holes at the base of the pan for adequate airflow.
Safe and Sound
This Pullman loaf pan features a nonstick silicone coating that is free from all harmful substances. So, there is no worry regarding the pan releasing toxic chemicals while baking at high temperatures.
The pan features a lid that helps to contain the heat better and bake the dough consistently. As a result, the loaf turns out to be very good.
Ease of Cleaning: Very Good!
It is very easy to clean. However, there’s no mention of it being dishwasher-safe. It is recommended to be washed by hand. For that, you will need warm water, liquid soap, and a gentle scrub.
Don’t scrub it very hard as that may peel the nonstick coating and make the pan unusable. Moreover, dry it quickly after washing and use cooking oil to season the pan before use.
8. KITESSENSU Pullman Loaf Pan with Lid
Eight on our list comes, the KITESSENSU Pullman Loaf Pan with Lid. It is a 1 lb capacity Pullman loaf pan. Made from alloy and carbon steel, this loaf pan is very durable and feels sturdy in hand.
The pan weighs around 1 pound and its dimensions are 8.3 x 4.8 x 4.53 inches. It can handle temperatures up to 446 degrees Fahrenheit or 230 degrees celsius.
Carbon Steel Pan
KITESSENSU Pullman loaf pans are made of sturdy, dependable carbon steel that delivers durability and speed. It has a food-grade silicone covering and does not leak Teflon at high temperatures.
It has reinforced borders. Therefore, it shouldn’t warp even in higher temperatures. So, you can concentrate on making yummy things!
Nonstick and Bottom Vent
You can simply remove bread from a black toast pan without causing any damage to its aesthetics, thanks to its nonstick coating. The baked goods slide very easily out of the pan.
It also features a bottom vent design which ensures that the dough is cooked evenly and has a stronger flavor. It ensures airflow as well and raises the dough perfectly for a baking delight.
This Pullman loaf pan cover can not only bake square bread, but it can also make bread toast. They can create great loaf bread and sandwich bread in your house based on your very convenient preferences.
In such uses, you can choose whether to use the cover or not to use it. Overall, this is a solid choice for a Pullman loaf pan.
9. ON Pullman Loaf Pan with Lid
Second last of our list in the Oak and Noble Pullman Loaf Pan with Lid. It is a traditional-style Pullman loaf pan with a wavy pattern across the surface. It gives quite an elegant feel.
The loaf pan weighs around 1.41 pounds and features a dimension of 8.39 x 4.75 x 4.33 inches. As can be assumed from the dimension, it is a rectangular loaf pan.
Lightweight and Compact
Despite being a rectangular medium-sized loaf pan, it feels very compact. The small footprint of this pan makes it easier to store and carry if needed. However, even if it is lightweight and compact, it is very strong and durable.
This pan can handle temperatures up to 440 degrees Fahrenheit, making it an optimal choice for high-temperature baking.
The gorgeous matt black surface of this pan has a non-toxic coating that makes it simple to remove the bread after baking. The nonstick layer is free of BPA and PFOA. So, you can bake without any worries.
The ribbed sides also aid in the bread's easy removal from the pan, all while creating a lovely pattern. They help with the even distribution of heat as well.
Comes with a Recipe Book!
This Oak and Noble Pullman loaf pan with cover includes a complimentary ebook with tasty recipes to help you start on your home baking quest. Among the recipes are chocolate chip banana bread, sandwich loaf, and many more.
It's a welcome addition. If you are new to baking, this tiny inclusion of an ebook can be beneficial for you. Overall, this is a pan that we can recommend to novice home bakers.
10. LI-GELISI Pullman Loaf Pan
If you are looking for a tiny Pullman loaf pan, then the last product on our list is perfect for you. It is the LI-GELISI Pullman Loaf Pan. It can bake 0.55 lb dough at once which is not very much.
The loaf pan weighs 0.86 pounds and has a dimension of 4.52 x 4.52 x 4.52 inches. Made from durable alloy steel, it can be the perfect compact choice.
Although this loaf pan is very compact, it doesn’t compromise its build quality. It has a tough build with a ribbed pattern running across its body. These patterns give the pan extra rigidity and help in heat distribution.
Apart from functionality, these ribbed patterns give the loaf an interesting look and make it eye-pleasing.
Whitford Nonstick Coat
This Pullman loaf pan features a Whitford nonstick coating. This coating helps to minimize dough sticking to the pan walls. Therefore, allows easy removal of baked goods. There is also a bottom hole in this pan.
The bottom hole ensures airflow inside of the bread, making it fluffy and flavorsome. It also helps with heat management in the pan.
Compact and Great Usability
This is a great choice if you want a travel loaf pan. Its compact size increases its transportability. It is also easy to use due to its small size. Cleaning a small pan is not a big challenge as well.
Overall, it is something that we can easily recommend to someone who is looking for a small square Pullman loaf pan.
What Is A Pullman Loaf Pan?
Before jumping into the realm of Pullman loaf pans, you need to have a clear idea about what it is and in which activity you can use it.
The Pullman loaf pan is a sandwich bread pan with a slide-on top that produces squared-off bread with a soft yet compressed crumb. These flat-topped bread prepared by the pans were simpler to pile.
Whereas the convex loaves cooked in normal pans can’t be stacked, making it difficult to store. Keeping the storing ease in mind, such pans were popularized and now almost all store-bought sandwich bread follow this method.
Although such pan designs prevailed previously, these boats are mainly associated with the tight flats of Pullman rail cars that existed in the 19th century. Thus, the name ‘Pullman loaf pan’ originated.
Now, let’s take a look at the top 10 Pullman loaf pans that caught the attention of our editors. You won’t go wrong if you buy any of these pans. However, we are allowing you the liberty to choose according to your preferences.
Comparison Chart of The Best Loaf Pans
|USA Pan Bakeware Pullman Loaf Pan
|13 x 4 x 4 inches
|CHEFMADE Mini Pullman Loaf Pan with Lid (Square)
|4.5 x 4.5 x 4.2 inches
|CHEFMADE Pullman Loaf Pan with Lid (Rectangular)
|8.4 x 4.8 x 4.5 inches
|Monfish Pullman Loaf Pan with Cover
|8.5 x 4.75 x 4.38 inches
|Focus Foodservice Pullman Bread Pan
|16 x 4 x 4 inches
|Twscvc Pullman Loaf Pan with Lid
|High Carbon Steel
|7.6 x 4 x 4.5 inches
|TA BEST UgyDuky Bakeware Pullman Loaf Pan
|13 x 4 x 4 inches
|KITESSENSU Pullman Loaf Pan with Lid
|Alloy Steel, Carbon Steel
|8.3 x 4.8 x 4.53 inches
|ON Pullman Loaf Pan with Lid
|8.39 x 4.75 x 4.33 inches
|LI-GELISI Pullman Loaf Pan
|4.52 x 4.52 x 4.52 inches
Things to Consider While Choosing A Pullman Loaf Pan
Pullman loaf pans are an essential component of any baking setup. As a result, they are extensively purchased. A nice Pullman loaf simplifies and boosts your confidence when baking.
An excellent Pullman loaf pan is difficult to choose among the number of variations available on the market. Furthermore, pans from various companies have distinct characteristics and aesthetics.
So, before you go out and buy the best Pullman loaf pan for you, there are a few things you should consider. These will assist you in making an educated decision and getting the best value for your money.
Design and Material Choices
In terms of construction materials, we've seen aluminum alloy, carbon steel, and stainless steel being used in the majority of Pullman loaf pans. You should be alright with any of these materials because they are great heat conductors.
However, be certain that the pans have a nonstick coating. It's upsetting to see your loaf become trapped on the pan and break as you're trying to pull it out.
Choosing a pan with some form of ribbed micro-texture and a bottom vent hole is also a good idea. These microtextures, as well as the bottom vent, provide for proper ventilation to the meal. Furthermore, they aid in the equal distribution of heat across the baking surface of the pan.
The pan's durability is mostly determined by the materials used in its construction. It is generally advisable to select a pan with rust resistance, anti-corrosion, and warp resistance guarantees.
You should avoid pans that are vulnerable to dents and stains, or pans that have a poor build quality. Check to see if the pans' edges are strengthened. It adds structural rigidity to the pan.
The maximum of the Pullman loaf pan isn’t dishwasher-safe. So, it should be cleaned by hand. If the pan needs additional scrubbing, that might peel its non-stick coating. So, choosing a pan that is easy to clean is key.
For that reason, we recommend you to buy medium-sized Pullman loaf pans as they are easily accessible while cleaning.
It completely depends on personal preferences. The key factor here is what you are planning to do with it and how much bread you need. For larger families, the requirement would be to buy a large Pullman loaf pan.
Whereas, a person who wants a loaf pan just to carry it with him on trips and visits, would be better off buying a 4.5 x 4.5 inches square Pullman loaf pan.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1. Can I wash my loaf pan in the dishwasher?
Answer: You can if it is dishwasher-safe. However, it is always recommended that you wash your Pullman loaf pan by hand (scrub less) if you want to use it for a long time.
Q2. Which loaf pan is better? Square or Rectangle?
Answer: Square and rectangle doesn’t refer to the shape of the bread. It usually indicates the size of the pan. Square loaf pans are generally smaller in size than rectangle pans.
Q3. Is it mandatory to season the pan before use?Answer: It depends on the type of pan. However, we generally recommend seasoning the pan a bit with some droplets of cooking oil. To find out if it is mandatory to season your pan or not, check the instruction manual.
Pullman loaf pan is a baking tool that every home baker should have. However, people get confused while buying a loaf pan like so many options are available out there. We hope you won’t get confused anymore.So, that’s all from our side today. Hope we could come in some help for you in choosing the best Pullman loaf pan for you. Enjoy your baking hobby and best of luck for your future.