If you are into baking then you already know what a jelly roll pan is. It is a baking pan/tray that is slightly smaller than the traditional baking sheets. Nowadays, it is widely referred to as a cookie tray and pizza pan. Because of its similarity in size with regular half-sheet baking pans, people face trouble distinguishing jelly roll pans. It can be a significant addition to your baking arsenal, thanks to the versatility that it offers.There are numerous uses of a good jelly roll pan. But what separates the best jelly roll pan from the worst ones, you may wonder. To determine this we have tried out many jelly roll pans and we think we got the answers. To make the choice easier for you, we are listing the top 15 jelly roll pans from our testing and guiding you towards choosing the right one for you. So, without any further ado, let’s go through them.
List of The 15 Best Jelly Roll Pans
1. OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Jelly Roll Pan
The first recommendation on our list is the OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Jelly Roll Pan. It is equipped with a double-layered non-stick ceramic coating that helps it to avoid any rust, corrosion, stain, and abrasion.
Excellent Build Quality
The jelly roll pan is entirely made of heavy gauge aluminized steel. It helps the heat to be evenly spread on the baking surface. The non-stick coating makes sure that the batter doesn’t stick to the pan surface or edges.
This commercial-grade ceramic coating prevents the pan from any type of discoloration. You can expect the pan to retain its original color even after repeated use. So, practically there’s no need to worry about its build quality.
Good Grip and Strength
The overall design of the pan is very sturdy. It features square roll edges that give the pan enough strength to handle use. This also makes sure that you get a good grip while you pick up the pan. It is very convenient to use.
Moreover, a good grip on the pan means there are fewer chances of dropping the pan while putting in or taking it out of the oven. It makes handling the jelly roll pan super-easy and very safe.
The Special Bits
The pan features micro-texture patterns on its baking surface. These patterns help the pan with proper heat division while baking as well as ensure good airflow in your food. So, the quality of baking is enhanced.
Furthermore, having textured patterns on the pan results in relatively less contact between your food and the pan. That reduces the possibility of the food getting stuck on the surface of the pan.
However, in terms of versatility, it lacks quite a bit. You should remain careful about not baking any protein on this jelly roll pan.
2. USA Pan Bakeware Jelly Roll Pan
The next pan on our list is the USA Pan Bakeware Jelly Roll Pan. It is a commercial-grade quality jelly roll pan that can be a great addition to a home as well as a professional baking setup.
Sturdy and Durable
Made from heavy-duty aluminized steel, this USA Pan Bakeware product feels solid and highly durable. It comes with a micro-texture pattern that adds to its rigidity while ensuring excellent airflow.
It also helps in terms of spreading the heat across the pan, leaving it with no cold spots. It ensures effective heating and cooling which makes this pan one of the most convenient jelly roll pan to work with.
Safety is Priority
The pan features a nonstick Americoat coating. It is a one-of-a-kind silicone coating that makes food release and cleanup easier. The pan is also certified as PTFE, PFOA, and BPA-free.
These certifications mean that it won’t adulterate your food by releasing any toxic substances. So, it doesn’t pose any type of risk to your health and you can use this pan without having to worry at all.
Versatile and Easy Clean
As it is a jelly roll pan, you already know it takes care of jelly rolls very well. What you may not know is that it can also be used to prepare cookies, cake, and other bakery foods. It can bake meats and veggies as well if you want to.
Cleaning after baking is very easy too for this pan. All you need is running water with a bit of liquid soap and a sponge. However, be very gentle while scrubbing it as the coating may come off if scrubbed aggressively.
3. Ultra Cuisine Baking Pan with Cooling Rack Set
The third on our list is the Ultra Cuisine Baking Pan with Cooling Rack Set. Designed in Colorado, USA; this pan is very well-built and convenient to use. It is the first shiny stainless steel pan on today’s list.
Premium Chrome Finish
Unlike the first two, this jelly roll pan has a shiny chrome finish to it which gives it a premium look. The pan is entirely made of 100 percent 304 stainless steel which feels very durable in hand and guarantees a good life.
The materials used to reinforce and coat the pan, all are food-grade. So, you don’t need to worry about your food safety.
Long-lasting and Convenient Cleaning
Designed with commercial grade aluminum and specialized stainless steel rim which prevent it from warping and provides a superior baking experience. You can easily use this for an extended period without having to worry.
Moreover, it is damn easy to clean. This pan is one of the few pans on our list that are dishwasher-safe. You can just load it up in the dishwasher and clean this puppy up in a snap. However, you may see some discoloration over time.
Comes with Cooling Rack
A big bonus in buying this package from Ultra Cuisine is that it comes bundled with a cooling rack. It is a very handy tool for a baking enthusiast. The cooling rack is also made from heavy-duty stainless steel.
Combining the pan with the cooling rack gives it additional versatility. You can easily use these two for baking, roasting, cooking, broiling, and even air frying. It is so useful and convenient!
4. Wilton Performance Pans Aluminum Jelly Roll and Cookie Pan
Up next comes the Wilton Performance Pans Aluminum Jelly Roll and Cookie Pan. It is a simple and traditional jelly roll pan that can get the job done without ringing any fancy bells and whistles.
Ideal Size Yet Super Light
If you bake food regularly, we believe you will enjoy working with this pan. It has the ideal size for repeated uses and is probably one of the lightest jelly roll pans that are currently available on the market.
However, it doesn’t compromise the build quality at all. The pan is made from premium quality aluminum alloy that is very durable and warp-resistant. It can spread the heat evenly and provide you with good baking experiences.
Commercial Grade Performance
This particular jelly roll pan is very handy. You can use it in both home and professional baking settings. Though it is a simpler pan than others on this list, it provides commercial-grade performance which is commendable.
It promises to treat you with fluffy and porous jelly rolls that you can enjoy with your family. In addition to that, it is quite versatile. You can bake, cook, roast, and fry easily on this pan without any headache.
Zero Cleaning Hassle
To clean this pan, all you would need is to rinse it with lukewarm soapy water. It is not suggested to scrub it aggressively. Rather clean it gently with care. Any rough treatment to it can leave noticeable scratches on its baking surface.
It is dishwasher safe as well. So, you can leave it on the top rack of your dishwasher with the other utensils and it should be fine. The only downside to this pan is, it doesn’t come with a nonstick coating which can be a deal-breaker.
5. Gorilla Grip Non-Stick Jelly Roll Baking Pans
This jelly roll baking pan comes in a set of three. It is the Gorilla Grip Non-Stick Jelly Roll Baking Pans. It features silicon grips for betting handling which sets it apart from the previous ones.
Durable Nonstick pans
These jelly roll pans are made from carbon steel which is very high-quality and durable. It resists warping, popping, and bending very well. It can endure very high temperatures and provide you with a good baking experience.
Pans made from carbon steel are great at spreading the heat properly across their surface. These pans come with a nonstick coating that helps to release food easily and leave no residue behind.
Equipped with silicone grips on the sides, these pans are quite convenient to handle. It doubles as a protection feature as it reduces the chances of letting the pans slip from the hand and cause an accident.
However, always use oven mitts while working with these pans. Although silicone isn’t a great conductor of heat, it can get warm enough to burn your fingers. So, beware!
So Many Colors!
If you are a person who enjoys having color options to choose from, these pans may be the right choice for you. The pans come in a variety of colors. However, the quality and features of the pans are consistent.
6. Nordic Ware Prism Baking Jelly Roll Pan
Next on our list is the Nordic Ware Prism Baking Jelly Roll Pan. Made from natural aluminum, it has some distinctive features that caught our eyes while researching for this article.
Prism Grid Design
With an embossed grid pattern on its baking surface, the Nordic Ware Prism Baking Jelly Roll Pan has a unique design that sets it apart from the rest of the pans on our list.
The prism grids add to the durability of the pan and make the pan very rigid. The texture of the surface allows the pan to spread heat evenly in all parts. You can expect crisp baking from it as well, thanks to the improved airflow.
The pan is built from natural aluminum with reinforced encapsulated steel rims. It provides toughness and helps it prevent warping. It can serve you quite a while if maintained properly.
Cleaning it is very straightforward. You need to rinse it with running water and liquid soap to retain a clean surface. It is not designed to be scrubbed aggressively as that might leave some scratches on the surface.
Value For Money
This jelly roll pan delivers serious value for the money it charges. Though it looks simple at first sight, the functionality it provides for such a low price is incredible and we highly recommend it.
7. Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Jelly Roll Pan
Up next comes Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Jelly Roll Pan. Perfect for preparing dishes such as jelly rolls, pastries, cookies, and muffins; this pan offers a nice deal.
Heavyweight and Warp-resistant
This heavyweight skillet is made from 19-gauge aluminum which is extremely durable. Featuring a reinforced beaded stainless steel wire rim, the pan can resist getting warped. It will easily outlast thousands of uses.
Safe for Chilling and Freezing
Despite being a baking tool, this pan can handle chilling and freezing very well. It is NSF approved and its non-porous surface helps it to distribute heat evenly. So, your jelly roll or pastries won’t come out underbaked.
It doesn’t come with a nonstick coating. However, cookies or cakes shouldn't come out sticky, thanks to their baking surface. It is rust and corrosion-proof. So, it doesn’t pose any health risk.
You can clean this puppy effortlessly using a sponge and maybe a bit of detergent. As it has a completely plain surface, it is relatively easier to clean and doesn’t leave any residue.
You can clean it in the dishwasher as well. Just don’t put it alongside knives, scrapers, brushes, cutters, or any sharp object.
8. Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Cookie/Jelly-Roll Pan
Another product on our list comes in a set. Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Cookie/Jelly-Roll Pan is perfect for those who are looking for a set of two jelly roll pans and a cooling rack.
A Value Bundle
Coming in a set of two pans and a cooling rack, this bundle screams incredible value for such an affordable price. This is ideal for baking multiple dishes together. An absolute bank for bucks deal!
Rigid Carbon Steel
The baking pan is built from heavy-weight carbon steel. It is an excellent conductor of heat and disperses heat evenly at all corners of the surface. This is great for a consistent baking experience.
It features a non-stick coating that allows it to easily release food as well as maintain regular cleaning. It is dishwasher-safe too. However, if you want to extend the lifetime of this pan, manual cleaning is recommended.
Space Saving Storage
Two pans and a cooling rack may seem like a storage nightmare if you have limited space on your kitchen shelf. However, you won’t need to worry about it as they are stackable. They will take the space that a regular baking pan takes.
9. Nordic Ware Jelly Roll Naturals Aluminum Nonstick
For the ninth entry in our list, we are going back to a very popular company that we already featured. Jelly Roll Naturals Aluminum Nonstick Pan from Nordic Ware is one of the best pans that you will find on the market right now.
The pan is constructed from natural aluminum to ensure rigidity as well as premium heat conductivity. It is a commercial-grade pan that holds up great with rust protection and ensures longevity.
The rims of the pan are strengthened with galvanized steel. So, it is resistant to dent, abrasion, and warp. Despite not having any handles, it is very comfortable to hold and work with.
Gold Non-stick Interior
The gold color on the pan looks very elegant and premium. It separates this Nordic Ware pan from the crowd of other pans. The pan is covered with a non-stick coat that repels food from sticking to the baking surface.
So, the food can be easily taken off the pan without any major deformation. It also makes cleaning the pan very easy and convenient.
Product of USA
This pan is designed and made in the USA. The company makes sure that every product that comes out of its manufacturing plant is quality-tested and consistent. So, Nordic Ware brand promise is something you can count on.
10. CasaWare Ultimate Series Commercial Weight Cookie/Jelly Roll Pan
Next is the CasaWare Ultimate Series Commercial Weight Cookie/Jelly Roll Pan. It comes in four colors. It looks very attractive and you will love it.
Constructed from carbon steel, this pan is built like a brick. The additional weight gives it a strong and sturdy feel in hand. It is made like it is supposed to last thousands of uses without showing any sign of breaking or warping.
Ceramic Non-stick Technology
This pan features ceramic non-stick technology. This technology makes it an easy-release baking tool. It also helps the pan to evenly distribute the heat and ensure a superior barking experience.
The pan is PTFE-free, cadmium-free, lead-free, PFOA, and PFOS free. So, it has zero health risks associated with it. You can easily keep on using it without having to worry for even a second.
This CasaWare pan is very easy to clean. After baking, just scrub the pan softly with soapy water and you are good to go. However, refrain from scrubbing the baking surface vigorously as it may result in permanent damage to the pan.
It comes with a care instructions manual that sheds more light on how to maintain this product.
11. KITCHENATICS Aluminum Jelly Roll Baking Pan
Looking for a heavy-duty jelly roll pan that will last a lifetime? You are at the right place. The KITCHENATICS Aluminum Jelly Roll Baking Pan is an extremely durable baking sheet that can certainly live up to your expectations.
More Than Just Durable
If you want perfect jelly rolls, this pan is an ideal size for you. Constructed from heavy-gauge aluminum, this pan provides full protection from any warp damage. It also features reinforced rims which adds to its structural integrity.
The rims are high enough not to overflow the pan while baking at a scorching temperature. You can comfortably grab the rims while putting the pan in and out of the oven which makes it very easy to use.
Apart from just perfect jelly rolls, you can use this pan for various other baking activities. You can prepare cookies, pastries, cakes, or any kind of dessert on it.
Not just desserts though! It can be used to bake, air fry, and roast meat and vegetables. It is a package full of delight if you can take advantage of its versatility properly.
The cooling rack made from 304 stainless steel is an amazing addition to this pan. The rack can hold up to 45 pounds of eight on its grates; so, it is considerably strong.
12. USA Pan Jelly Roll Baking Pan With Rack
We have already included a USA Pan jelly roll pan in our list. This next product is very similar to that one; however, it comes with a stainless steel cooling rack.
This USA Pan Bakeware product is made of heavy-duty aluminized steel. It feels robust and long-lasting. It has a micro-texture design that enhances stiffness as well as allows good ventilation to the food.
It also aids in the distribution of heat around the pan, ensuring that there are no cold areas. It enables efficient heating and cooling, making it one of the most practical jelly roll pans to use.
Safe and Multi-purpose
The pan has an Americoat nonstick coating. It's a unique silicone covering that helps with food release. In addition, the pan is PTFE, PFOA, and BPA-free which means there's no health risk in using this pan.
Apart from baking jelly rolls, this pan can also be used to make cookies, cakes, and other bakery items. If you desire, you may also bake meats and vegetables.
It comes with a cooling rack which is proven to be a very handy tool in baking. The pan and rack are very easy to clean. You can clean it using hot water, light soap, and a delicate sponge.
13. Doughmakers Jelly Roll Commercial Grade Aluminum Bake Pan
Taking the thirteenth position on our list is the Doughmakers Jelly Roll Commercial Grade Aluminum Bake Pan. It is one of the most elegant and premium baking pans on our list, thanks to its classy build.
Professional bakers use this pan because of characteristics like the incorporated marble pebble texture, which offers a quality non-stick experience. It looks and feels so good!
This particular texture also allows for enough ventilation, which is necessary for smooth baking. Because the heat is uniformly dispersed around the pan, your meal will not have any peculiar scorched patches.
Sturdy and Efficient
Made from 18 gauge commercial quality aluminum, you won't have to worry about this product's durability or hunt for substitutes after a few uses. It has a very quick heating and cooling cycle, which decreases baking time.
Moreover, as the pan is non-stick, you won't need to apply any additional grease or cooking sprays before pouring your batter into it. This leads to healthy and efficient baking.
Because it's constructed of recyclable aluminum, it's safe for the environment. In addition to that, unlike other non-stick cookware, this pan is devoid of PTFE and PFOA, ensuring that your food is free of any dangerous ingredients.
The only downside to this pan is, it isn’t completely scratch-proof.
14. Wilton Recipe Right Cookie/Jelly Roll Pan
The second last baking pan in our today’s list is the Wilton Recipe Right Cookie/Jelly Roll Pan. It is a low-priced aluminum jelly roll pan that gets the job done quite convincingly.
For the price, this jelly roll pan provides excellent value. Though it appears to be basic at first glance, the functionality it offers for such a low price is fantastic, and we strongly suggest it.
Made from aluminum, it’s quite durable and sturdy. It features extended areas on the horizontal ends to ensure a good grip while working with the pan.
Easy Release and Clean
This is an easy-release pan, which means you don’t need to do any hassle while taking the food out of the pan. It ensures that the item you have baked can be retrieved to a plate without any deformation.
It's also dishwasher safe. So, you may put it on the top rack of your dishwasher with the rest of your utensils and it should be okay. However, if you choose to clean it by hand, make sure you don’t scrub it too hard.
Limited 5-Year Warranty
The Wilton Recipe comes with a limited 5-year warranty. For a product at such an affordable price point, it is impressive.
However, we are unsure about how it will hold up after vigorous use. This particular pan doesn’t feel as well-built as others in this list. So, that’s one thing you should keep in mind.
15. All-Clad Pro-Release Nonstick Bakeware Jelly Roll Pan
The final baking pan on our list is the All-Clad Pro-Release Nonstick Bakeware Jelly Roll Pan. It is a well-built aluminized steel pan that screams quality.
Easy to Grip
A problem with many jelly roll baking pans is that they are hard to grip. Not the case with this one though. All-Clad Pro-Release series features oversized grip handles to make sure you have a good grasp of it.
Good grips can reduce the risk of you accidentally dropping the pan. Though it is not a must-have, having something to hold onto is convenient.
Hefty and Smooth Build
The jelly roll pan is composed of heavy-gauge aluminized steel with two layers of nonstick ceramic reinforcement. It is scratch and stain-resistant, and it readily releases food batch after batch.
Just by taking it in hand, you can tell that this skillet is premium quality. Overall, the build and finishing of this baking pan are very smooth.
The non-stick ceramic coat covering the entire pan is PFOA-free. It doesn’t pose any threat to the environment. It is also safe from scraping up. So, there’s no chance that your food will be contaminated by using this pan.
It is one of the expensive pans on this whole list which we see as a downside of this amazing product.
Comparison Chart of The Best Jelly Roll Pans
Things To Consider Before Purchasing A Jelly Roll Pan
Jelly roll pans are an important part of baking setups. Thus, they are heavily bought. A good jelly roll pan makes your baking activity convenient and gives you confidence.
Among the plethora of options available in the market, a good jelly roll pan is tough to recognize. Moreover, pans from different brands offer different unique features and styles.
So, while going on to purchase the best jelly roll pan for you, it's important to keep some things in mind. These will help you to make an informed choice and you can get the best value for your hard-earned cash.
1. Build Material and Design
In terms of build material, we have seen the use of anodized aluminum and heavy-duty stainless steel in most of the jelly roll pans. Both of the materials are excellent heat conductors and you should be okay with both.
However, you should make sure that the pans come with a nonstick coating. It is heartbreaking to see your food getting stuck on the pan and breaking its shape while taking it out of the pan.
Also, choosing a pan that features some sort of micro-texture is a good decision. These micro textures enable adequate airflow to the food. Moreover, they help to spread the heat evenly throughout the baking surface of the pan.
2. Durability and Maintenance
The durability of the pan primarily depends on its build materials. It is always recommended to choose a pan that comes with rust resistance, anti-corrosion, and warp-resistance assurance.
You must avoid pans that are prone to dents and scratches, in other words, pans with a bad build quality. Check if the edges of the pans are reinforced or not. It gives the pan additional structural integrity.
To retain the longevity of the pans, maintenance is very important. Pans that are easier to maintain, for example- dishwasher-safe and resistant to discoloration, should be a thing to consider while purchasing a pan.
If possible, finding brands that provide a warranty on the jolly roll pans should come in real handy.
3. Ease of Use and Versatility
While choosing to buy a jelly roll pan, you should always target the pans that are easy to work with. For instance, pans that offer handles on the sides are easy to grab. Having a good grip on the pan is important.
A greater grip on the pan reduces the chances of you dropping it and makes you less prone to accidents. Another that you might want to look for in a jelly roll pan is versatility.
Other than just baking jelly rolls and cookies, the pans should be able to handle other foods and allow you to reheat foods if needed. If the pan is not versatile, it restricts you from using the pan to its full potential.
4. Surface Size
Although the regular jelly roll pans come in more or less the same dimensions, it is necessary to make sure whether it fits in your oven or not. Also, some brands offer pans of different sizes. So, ensuring that you order the correct surface size is mandatory.
If you have a large baking oven in your home, then you should pick a size depending on the quantity of food that you plan to bake. For instance, baking for a large family will always require a larger pan.
However, know that large jelly roll pans are a bit difficult to store than small pans. Also, smaller pans feature greater ease of use than large ones.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1. What is the dimension of a perfect jelly roll pan?
Answer: There’s no one-perfect size for jelly roll pans. It is quite similar to cookie sheets or baking sheets. The dimensions for a common all-purpose jelly roll pan are either 15.5 x 10.5 inches or 18 x 12 inches with a 1-inch depth.
Q2. Can I use a half sheet pan instead of a jelly roll pan?
Answer: It depends on what you plan to do on that pan. If you are trying to bake a jelly roll cake, using a half sheet pan instead of a jelly roll pan can result in a thin and burnt cake which we are sure you don’t want.
Q3. Can I use a jelly roll pan to make cookies?
Answer: Yes, you certainly can. Nowadays, jelly roll pans are heavily used in making cookies and pizza. It has become so common that people have started to refer to jelly roll pan like a cookie tray and pizza pan!
Q4. Why is my new jelly roll pan warped?
Answer: Putting a rimless pan into a high-temperature oven makes the pan expand and eventually warp. Usually, you can hear a loud clang from your oven when the pan gets warped.
Q5. How to fix a warped pan?
Answer: There’s no certainty that you will be able to fix that at home. You can try tapping the bulge back at its place, it’s unlikely to fix it perfectly. A warped pan is frustrating to work with as it spreads the heat poorly and wobbles a lot.
Wrapping It Up!
To make baking convenient, jelly roll pans are a must-have. It is a versatile baking tool that you can use to elevate your baking experience. If you haven’t owned a jelly roll pan yet, we highly recommend you to purchase one.
If you face any difficulty in choosing the best jelly roll pan, let us reassure you that you can just pick any one of our recommendations without having to worry at all. These pans are top-notch and will help you a lot in baking.
That’s all from us today. We hope we could come to your help by guiding you towards a good jelly roll pan that you were missing in your baking arsenal.
Please let us know if you think we missed anything. We appreciate your feedback a lot and thanks for sticking to the end. Best of luck in your future endeavors. Happy baking!